|
Treating stuttering
While there are many treatments for stuttering, there is little consensus among
experts about which ones to use. Treatments vary from country to
country and vary even within countries. Some experts think it preferable
to treat stuttering as soon as it begins, while others suggest that
parents wait for a year or so to see whether the stuttering goes
away naturally. There is also little agreement about what type of
treatments to use with young children who have started to stutter.
Treatments may be direct (focusing directly on speech and stuttering)
or indirect (focusing on changing factors other than the speech
itself, such as parental communication style).
.jpg)
There is also little consensus about what treatments to use for older children
and adults who stutter. Most experts do agree, however, that once
stuttering is chronic, one goal of treatment is to help people control
their stuttering and so make it less handicapping. One approach
is for the person to find ways of making their stuttering less severe
and so more acceptable in communicative situations. Another approach
involves the person adopting a way of speaking that stops stuttering
altogether. Some treatments combine both approaches. Whatever approach
is adopted for older children and adults, current treatments typically
address the person's attitudes to speaking and confidence in communicative
contexts, as well as helping them to speak without stuttering.
Staff at the Australian Stuttering Research Centre favour an evidence based
approach to treatment for stuttering. This means that treatments
are favoured if they are backed by scientific research to support
their effectiveness. For that reason, we recommend the Lidcombe
Program for children, and a procedure known as Prolonged-Speech
for adults and adolescents. Our research at the Australian Stuttering
Research Centre has included the Lidcombe Program, and also the
development of a Prolonged-Speech treatment known as the Camperdown
Program. You can read about the Lidcombe
Program and the Camperdown Program
at other places on this website, and you can also download treatment
manuals and other clinical materials.

The range of available treatments may seem confusing
to a parent whose child is stuttering, or to adolescents and adults
who stutter and who are seeking help. Our position at the ASRC is
that people seeking treatment need to be fully informed before making
a decision. We suggest that it is sensible to ask a prospective
therapist not only about the nature of the treatment he or she offers
but also whether the treatment has an evidence base (see above).
We suggest that published scientific evidence that supports a particular
treatment is the most important factor to consider when deciding
to participate in a treatment program.
Information for parents
If your preschooler is stuttering, we offer the following suggestions:
- Seek out a speech pathologist who has experience with early stuttering
and who has been trained in the Lidcombe Program. High quality standardised
training in the program has been available in many countries around
the world since 2003. For further information click on the link
to the Lidcombe Program Trainers
Consortium (LPTC).
- The Lidcombe Program should be done according
to the manual. You can check this by downloading the
Lidcombe Program manual
from this website. It is available in a variety of languages.
The Lidcombe
Program brochure also provides an overview of the treatment.
At the moment the research team at the ASRC is developing other
ways of implementing the program (eg. via distance, in groups) and
further results will be available in the future.
- Steady improvement in stuttering, evident at home as well as in the clinic,
should be seen throughout Stage 1 of the program. Children vary
enormously in the time taken to complete Stage 1 of the program;
from a few weeks to around six months. If you have any questions
or concerns about your child's progress through the program,
you should raise them with your speech pathologist. Speech pathologists
can contact Consortium members
for advice about the Lidcombe Program.
|